A Study to Compare the Cognitive Function
of Children Belonging to Employed and Unemployed Mothers at a Selected School
at Chennai
Prof A. Arvin Babu
M.Sc (Nursing),
Principal, Dhanvantri College of Nursing, Ganapathypuram, NO – 1 Ranganoor
Road, Muniyappan Kovil, Pallakkapalyam, Namakkal District
– 637 303
E-mail: sagaarvin@ymail.com
ABSTRACT
Background: The school age
children consistently indicate that children of employed mothers are as
confident in social settings and are more sociable with peers than children
whose mothers remain at home. Objectives: To compare the cognitive function
between children belonging to employed and unemployed mothers. Design: A
comparative descriptive design was adopted for the study. Setting: The study
was conducted in KVM Matriculation School, Iyyappanthangal
at Chennai. Participants: The sample of the study included 30 children
belonging to employed mothers and 30 children belonging to unemployed mothers
between the age group of 5 to 10 years, fulfilling the inclusion criteria were
selected by Stratified sampling technique. Methods: Baseline Proforma of sample and Binet – Kamath Intelligent test was administered to assess the
cognitive function of children belonging to employed and unemployed mothers
participants were interviewed 20 – 30 minutes to complete the test. Results:
The findings revealed that the mean value for the cognitive function of
children belonging to employed mothers was 81.5 and SD was 11.4. The mean value
and SD for the cognitive function of children belonging to unemployed mothers
found to be 81.0 and 11.5. Student t – test proved that there was no
significant difference between employed and unemployed mothers. Level of
cognitive function of children reveals that 40% of children belonging to
employed mothers were between the intelligent quotient of 81 -90 (Dull). The
same time, 33% of children belonging to unemployed mothers were between the
intelligent quotient of 70 -80 (Borderline). There was no significant
association with cognitive function of children belonging to employed and unemployed mothers with demographic
variables Conclusion: The study concluded that no significant association
between the cognitive function of children belonging to employed and unemployed
mothers.
KEY WORDS: Cognitive Function, Mothers, Children
INTRODUCTION:
Ira Das and Reena
Mathew (1997) concluded that the role of women in society has radically changed
and is still changing in most of the developing countries. In India, during
last four or five decades tremendous changes have been
seen in the status and position of women in society. The rural women of low
socio economic status, who constitute about 80% of the population in India,
have been found in their occupational status with the development of technology
and education. As a result of this educational expansion a new section of women
called working women has emerged and is rapidly expanding.
Kiran Mathur and Girishwar Misra (1997) suggested
that employed mothers are more caustions and aware
about the physical, psychological and intellectual needs of
their children and they try to provide all types of support to their children,
although they have to manage their times according to the needs of family and
employment.
Gold and Andres (1978) said school age
children consistently indicate that children of employed mothers are as
confident in social settings and are more sociable with peers than children
whose mothers remain at home.
Clarke-Stewart (1989), Hoffman (1989)
suggested that the young children whose mothers are employed are more
aggressive and less obedient than children care by their mother.
Bronfenbrenner (1986);
Gold and Andres( 1978) found that middle class boys of working mothers
tend to score lower in intelligence and academic achievement than boys whose
mothers not employed. Particularly when their mothers work
more than 40 hours a week.
Balk and Christoffel
(1988), Binachi and Spalin
(1986), observed that the mother’s status as working women has not been found
consistently to have either positive or negative effects on children’s
development and educational outcomes.
Belsky (1988), found that working women who
scored high as measures of emotional well being, sensitivity to accept and
acceptance of their children, satisfaction with non work time and positive
feelings about their marriage were more likely to have securely attached
infant, regardless of child care arrangements.
The investigator had observed during his
experience that there is significant change in cognitive function of children
in relation to maternal employment. This information ca
lead to more appropriate nursing care for cognitive function of children
subjected to employed and unemployed mothers. So the investigator was motivated
to probe the cognitive function of children subjected to employed and
unemployed mothers.
McGroder (2000), observed
that children’s scores on measures of cognitive school readiness and personal
maturity were significant predictors of parenting pattern; children’s verbal
ability was no longer related to parenting pattern once significant maternal
characteristics were controlled. Maternal characteristics are maternal
education, duration of welfare and age at first birth.
McGroder (2000), found
that, children’s cognitive school readiness and personal maturity were
significantly related to parenting pattern; even after controlling for
significant predictors of parenting pattern; children’s verbal ability was no
longer related to parenting pattern once significant maternal characteristics
were controlled.
STATEMENT
OF PROBLEM
A study to compare the cognitive function
of children belonging to employed and unemployed mothers at a selected school
at Chennai
OBJECTIVES
1. To identify the demographic variables of
children belonging to employed and unemployed mothers
2. To assess the cognitive function of
children belonging to employed mothers
3. To assess the cognitive function of
children belonging to unemployed mothers
4. To compare the cognitive function between
children belonging to employed and unemployed mothers
5. To find the association between demographic
variables and the cognitive function of children belonging to employed and
unemployed mothers
HYPOTHESIS
H1 : There is significant difference in
cognitive function of children belonging to employed and unemployed mothers.
METHODS AND MATERIALS:
RESEARCH
APPROACH AND RESEARCH DESIGN
A comparative descriptive method, which
helps to provide factual information about existing phenomena
SETTING
OF THE STUDY
The study was conducted in KVM Matriculation
School, Iyyappanthangal at Chennai
POPULATION
Children belonging to employed and
unemployed mothers
SAMPLE,
SAMPLE SIZE AND SAMPLING TECHNIQUE
The sample of the study included 30
children belonging to employed mothers and 30 children belonging to unemployed
mothers between the age group of 5 to 10 years, selected by stratified random
sampling technique.
DEVELOPMENT
OF TOOL
Section A : A structured interview schedule
was developed to identify the demographic variables of children included age,
sex, religion, economic status of the family , educational status of the
mother, siblings, peers, type of family, location of the family , mass media,
health status of the children, test marks , attendance and doing home work.
Section B: Binet
– Kamath Intelligent test was administered to assess
the cognitive function of children belonging to employed and unemployed
mothers.
PLAN FOR DATA ANALYSIS
The data were
analysed by using both descriptive and inferential statistics
Ø Baseline
proforma of the samples were described by frequency
and percentage distribution
Ø Mean,
standard deviation and mean percentage was used to assess the cognitive function of children belonging to
employed and unemployed mothers
Ø Student ‘t’ test was used to compare the
cognitive function of children belonging to employed and unemployed mothers
Ø Chi
square test was used to find out the relationship between demographic variables and the cognitive
function of children belonging to employed and unemployed mothers.
RESULTS:
Section
1: Related to demographic variables:
Children
of employed mothers
·
Most
(37%) of children were 9 years of age
·
60 %
of children were male
·
Most
(90%) of the Hindu
·
Most
(93%) of children health status are healthy
·
27% of
mothers were degree holder
·
60% of
them were nuclear family
·
40% of
them were economic status of between Rs 2001 – 3000
·
Most
(40% ) of children attendance between 71% to 80%
·
Most
(57% ) of children rank between 1 - 10
·
Most
(43% ) of children doing homework regularly
Children
of unemployed mothers
·
Most
(37%) of children were 7 years of age
·
47 %
of children were male
·
Most
(97%) of the Hindu
·
Most
(80%) of children health status are healthy
·
43% of
mothers were higher secondary
·
77% of
them were nuclear family
·
47% of
them were economic status of between Rs 2001 – 3000
·
Most
(43% ) of children attendance between 71% to 80%
·
Most
(40% ) of children failed
·
Most
(30% ) of children doing homework regularly
Section
2: The mean value for the
cognitive function of children belonging to employed mothers was 81.5 and SD was
11.4. The mean value and SD for the cognitive function of children belonging to
unemployed mothers found to be 81.0 and 11.5. Student t – test proved that
there was no significant difference between employed and unemployed mothers.
Section
3: Level of cognitive
function of children reveals that 40% of children belonging to employed mothers
were between the intelligent quotient of 81 -90 (Dull). The same time, 33% of
children belonging to unemployed mothers were between the intelligent quotient
of 70 -80 (Borderline).
Section
4: There was no
significant association with cognitive function of children belonging to
employed and unemployed mothers with demographic variables like age, sex,
religion, economic status of the family , educational status of the mother,
siblings, peers, type of family, location of the family , mass media, health
status of the children, test marks , attendance and doing home work.
CONCLUSION:
Based on
above findings of the study, implications and recommendation were drawn for nursing
service, administration, education and research. The study concluded that no
significant association between the cognitive function of children belonging to
employed and unemployed mothers.
RECOMMENDATION
·
A
similar study could be conducted to the larger sample for the cognitive
function of children belonging to employed and unemployed mothers.
·
Different
models of nursing interventions would be systematically tried with cognitive
function of children belonging to employed and unemployed mothers.
·
A similar
comparative study could be conducted for the emotional development of children
belonging to employed and unemployed mothers.
·
A
similar comparative study could be conducted for the behavioral problems
children belonging to employed and unemployed mothers
·
A
similar comparative study could be conducted for the cognitive function
preschool children belonging to employed and unemployed mothers
·
A
comparative study can be undertaken to compare the problems faced by the
employed and unemployed mothers.
REFERENCES:
1.
Donna
L Wong (1995). Nursing care of Infants and Children, 5th edition, Philadelphia : Mosby.
2.
Irene
M Bobak (1999). Maternity Nursing. 5th
edition, Philadelphia : Mosby.
3.
Mary
Ellen Aver, Lewis R First (1994). Paediatric Medicine
2nd edition. Philadelphia : Williams and
Wilkins.
4.
Mary
Ann Boyd and MaryAn Nihart
(1994). Psychiartic Nursing, Philadelphia
: Lippincott.
5.
Mary
CJ Rudolf and Malcom I Levene
(1999). Pediartics and Child Health
, Victoria, Blackwell Science.
Received on 05.07.2012 Modified on
15.07.2012
Accepted on 22.07.2012 © A&V Publication all right reserved
Asian J. Nur. Edu. and Research 2(3): July-Sept.
2012; Page 104-106